European University Institute Library

The role and extent of a proportionality analysis in the judicial assessment of human rights limitations within international criminal proceedings, by Nicolas A. J. Croquet

eng

no index present

non fiction

The role and extent of a proportionality analysis in the judicial assessment of human rights limitations within international criminal proceedings

electronic resource

dictionaries

932593795

by Nicolas A. J. Croquet

Brill E-Books

"The aim of this monograph is to analyze how the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and the International Criminal Court have resorted to proportionality and other limitation techniques when placing implied external limits upon the exercise of substantive and procedural human rights enjoyed by the accused and other actors affected by international criminal proceedings. Implied external limits in this context are defined as those limits that override the exercise of a human right on public interest grounds or on grounds relating to competing human rights and that either fall outside the scope of a limitation/qualification clause of an international criminal court's internal legal instruments or go beyond its express and ordinary terms. The present monograph will point to various sources of legal uncertainty which international criminal courts have generated in the limitation process of those human rights relevant to international criminal proceedings and to the definition of international crimes. The monograph will examine the relation between human rights, limitations on human rights standards and proportionality under international criminal procedural law and international criminal law (understood substantively) in light of the limitation and proportionality practices of international human rights monitoring bodies."--, Provided by Publisher

Introduction: Purpose, Methodology and Scope of the Monograph -- Conceptual Tools for Assessing Limitations upon the Exercise of Human Rights -- Institutional and Regulatory Context Underpinning the International Criminal Courts' Human Rights Limitation Analyses -- Formation of a Generic Justificatory Framework for Assessing External Limits upon any Fundamental Right or Defence Right -- Implied External Limits on the Right to Self-Representation through the Assignment of Defence Counsel and of Standby Counsel -- Implied External Limits on the Right to Cross-Examination through Absolute Witness Anonymity and Rolling Disclosure Measures -- Implied External Limits upon the Accused's Rights to Efffective Participation in his Trial and to be Presumed Innocent -- Incidental Implied External Limits Placed upon Substantive Human Rights: The Rights to Freedom of Expression and to Privacy -- Implied Internal Limit Placed on the Right of Silence and Judicial Refusal to Place Any Implied Limits on the Right Not to Self-Incriminate