The Resource Using historical experience : the British Army and the Bundeswehr in Afghanistan, Eric Sangar

Using historical experience : the British Army and the Bundeswehr in Afghanistan, Eric Sangar

Label
Using historical experience : the British Army and the Bundeswehr in Afghanistan
Title
Using historical experience
Title remainder
the British Army and the Bundeswehr in Afghanistan
Statement of responsibility
Eric Sangar
Creator
Contributor
Subject
Language
eng
Summary
This PhD explores some of the ways in which the British and German Armies have used historical experience in their process of operational adaptation in Afghanistan. Historical experience is conceptualized as a body of useful knowledge that is constructed through the institutional analyses of past military campaigns with the aim of producing normative lessons for military operations in the present. Empirically, the research shows that for both armies, the use of historical references played a limited role during the preparation of initial deployment for the ISAF mission. However, having become aware of a lack of operational coherence on the ground in Helmand, the British Army "rediscovered" the importance of applying fundamental counterinsurgency principles that were identified with a comparative analysis of colonial counterinsurgency campaigns. This process has contributed to improve officers' consensual understanding of doctrine on the part of the officers as well as to make the British military approach in Afghanistan more coherently focused on protecting the population rather than pursuing a predominantly kinetic confrontation with the insurgency movement. With regards to the Bundeswehr, a thorough discussion of the historical experiences that have potential utility for military operations in Afghanistan has been largely absent. Initially, the German military approach was dominated primarily by an unconscious reliance on the operational design used in the Balkans. The operational reaction to the escalating violence in the Kunduz area has primarily consisted in a hesitant introduction of kinetic means, while existing deficits in non-kinetic military activities have largely been ignored. Similarly, operational debate among Bundeswehr officers has been focused on the necessity to perform in combat; implications of counterinsurgency operations for non-kinetic military tasks, such as the support of the local population, have received only marginal attention. I argue that this tendency could have been limited has an internal debate taken place on the historical lessons that incorporate the concepts used in contemporary Anglo-Saxon counterinsurgency. In sum, three primary findings of this research may be recapitulated as follows: First, the mere existence of a rich institutional past of colonial operations does not necessarily equate with superior knowledge in contemporary operations. Historical experience must be actively transmitted, analysed and institutionalised in order to have such an effect. Second, the ways in which military organizations use experience from the past are shaped by institutional traditions that have evolved over time. Third, despite the danger of dysfunctional historical analogies, the institutional discussion of historical lessons can prove to be useful for present operations - especially if consistency is promoted through consensually applied, 'enduring' principles of doctrine
Member of
Cataloging source
IT-FiEUI
http://library.link/vocab/creatorName
Sangar, Eric
Date time place
Defence date: 6 June 2012
Dissertation note
Thesis (Ph. D.)--European University Institute (SPS), 2012.
Index
no index present
Literary form
non fiction
Nature of contents
theses
http://library.link/vocab/relatedWorkOrContributorName
European University Institute
Series statement
  • EUI PhD theses
  • EUI theses
http://library.link/vocab/subjectName
  • Peace-building
  • Afghan War, 2001-
  • Great Britain
  • Great Britain
  • Germany
  • Germany
Label
Using historical experience : the British Army and the Bundeswehr in Afghanistan, Eric Sangar
Instantiates
Publication
Note
Examining board: Professor Pascal Vennesson (European University Institute); Professor Michael Daxner (Freie Universität Berlin); Professor Anthony King (University of Exeter); Professor Olivier Roy (European University Institute)
Bibliography note
Includes bibliographical references (pages 279-298)
Carrier category
volume
Carrier category code
nc
Carrier MARC source
rdacarrier.
Content category
text
Content type code
txt
Content type MARC source
rdacontent.
Control code
FIEb17095700
Dimensions
30 cm.
Extent
viii, 299 pages
Media category
unmediated
Media MARC source
rdamedia.
Media type code
n
Other physical details
Illustrations
System control number
(OCoLC)871271922
Label
Using historical experience : the British Army and the Bundeswehr in Afghanistan, Eric Sangar
Publication
Note
Examining board: Professor Pascal Vennesson (European University Institute); Professor Michael Daxner (Freie Universität Berlin); Professor Anthony King (University of Exeter); Professor Olivier Roy (European University Institute)
Bibliography note
Includes bibliographical references (pages 279-298)
Carrier category
volume
Carrier category code
nc
Carrier MARC source
rdacarrier.
Content category
text
Content type code
txt
Content type MARC source
rdacontent.
Control code
FIEb17095700
Dimensions
30 cm.
Extent
viii, 299 pages
Media category
unmediated
Media MARC source
rdamedia.
Media type code
n
Other physical details
Illustrations
System control number
(OCoLC)871271922

Library Locations

    • Badia FiesolanaBorrow it
      Via dei Roccettini 9, San Domenico di Fiesole, 50014, IT
      43.803074 11.283055
Processing Feedback ...